Thread:Scrooge200/@comment-37918756-20191124034823/@comment-43797581-20191124062506

Scrooge200 wrote: Arthur Read fan wrote: On the Arthur Read fan Scale, it's a 3/10, not even close to a 10+. The plot is WAY too similar to "Crime and Consequences" for my liking (Actually, I like "Crime and Consequences", but I don't like "The Tattletale Frog"). A character gets unfairly blamed for something they didn't even do (In "Crime and Consequences", it's Binky; in "The Tattletale Frog", it's Bud), and the character that actually caused the problem has to 'fess up (In "Crime and Consequences", it's George; in "The Tattletale Frog", it's DW).

Still, I'd rather take this episode over "DW and Dr. Whosit" anyday.

That is all for now. Have a wonderful kind of day!

-Arthur Read fan Whoa, you have a ratings scale? I never knew that! You should rate some more episodes, I'd love to hear what you think about some of them.

You would!? Thanks! There are several episodes I like, and I can give you some of my episode ratings right now if you like.

For instance...

In my opinion, The Secret Origin of Supernova is a 9/10 on the Arthur Read fan Scale.

Get Smart is an 8/10 on the Arthur Read fan Scale.

and DW and Dr. Whosit is a 1/10 on the Arthur Read fan Scale.

Those are just a few examples, plus my rating of "The Tattletale Frog" (3/10). In fact, if you want, you can go to my profile, where I have a list of my favourite episodes, and why I like them. I'll be sure to give more episode ratings later!

One last thing: I'm also currently working on an Arthur Fanfiction that I will put into a Blog Post the day before Thanksgiving. It's called, "The Thanksgiving Incident".

"The Thanksgiving Incident" is about Arthur, DW, Buster, and Brain (with the help of Mrs. Read) planning the perfect replacement Thanksgiving Dinner for Mr. Read after Pal ruins Mr. Read's freshly cooked Turkey (as well as trampling everything else on the table). It's funny, educational, and it has a nice ending. I hope you'll look forward to seeing it when I publish the Blog Post on Wednesday, November 27th, 2019! Until then, have a wonderful kind of day!

-Arthur Read fan