Talk:Season 23/@comment-38894670-20191105231249/@comment-43797581-20191106083228

I like your ideas, although I'll admit that I don't really understand the second one. (But that's just my opinion.)

As far as the idea you have called "Cousin John": To me, it sounds like a rehash of "The Perfect Brother" (which happened in Season 1, by the way), and I kind of doubt they would do another rehash of that story idea, since Season 17's "Dog's Best Friend" kind of sort of already did that (in concept, not the characters). And speaking of characters, I'm kind of curious as to why you called the episode "Cousin John", since (as far as we know), Arthur doesn't have a cousin named John. Unless if you're referring to John Legend (I'm not saying that you are, I was just curious, since there are several internet memes of Legend being like Arthur).

As far as "Liar Liar, Pants on Fire" goes: As I said earlier in this comment, I don't understand this one. Like, why would they do an episode about Francine lying about a homework assignment? That doesn't make sense to me in my opinion.

Finally, for your idea entitled, "Welcome to Christmas": I actually celebrate Christmas, so I know full well what the true meaning of Christmas is. But this idea seems more like a partial rehash of Season 4's "1001 Dads" than an actual Christmas episode to me in my opinion. And plus, they have the special "Arthur's Perfect Christmas" for the Christmas and Holiday theme (but it's a shame that PBS doesn't show it every year, even though it's a Christmas / Holiday special. For instance, they didn't air it in 2014, 2016, or 2017, and they're not even airing it this year, 2019).

To reiterate: While I like some of your ideas, the majority of them sound too similar to already-existing episodes to me in my opinion. But I do hope you have a wonderful kind of day, and I also look forward to seeing when Season 24 will release (based on PBS schedules, it won't be until 2020 at least).

Alright, I've got to wrap up this already-long comment. (Sorry if I got slightly off-topic!) Have a wonderful kind of day!

-Arthur Read fan