Talk:D.W. and the Beastly Birthday/@comment-32560263-20200127023500/@comment-43797581-20200127031259

You know, Scrooge200, before you re-mentioned that flaw, I had completely forgotten about it LOL (it shows how unmemorable D.W. and the Beastly Birthday really is).

Yeah, like, what the heck? Bud wasn't in Elwood City at that point, and on top of that, he would've been still a baby! That is a pretty major flaw with the story, although it was D.W.'s dream...

And speaking of dreams, I didn't really like Arthur's dream in this special either. It was just too weird. (Although, dreams can be weird sometimes. I speak from experience.)

But either way, I don't get why they did a whole special about D.W.'s fifth birthday, when she already had her fifth birthday in "D.W.'s Perfect Wish," which was back nearly two decades before this was released. Thankfully, "The Rhythm and Roots of Arthur" is a MUCH better special than this.

Before I wrap this up (no pun intended, because this is a birthday special), I want to point out another possible flaw:

Hoverboards can be dangerous, and I don't think that they would let 8, 9-year-olds ride hoverboards. I'm pretty sure that there are safety rules and liabilities that would come with such actions.

-Arthur Read fan